Prof Andy Brooks
NAPC Clinial Chair
It is just over a year since I became Clinical Chair of NAPC. When I started, neighbourhood health had moved firmly into the centre of the national conversation, closely aligning with what NAPC has always been about: starting with populations, improving care and supporting innovation rooted in primary care.
Over the past year, I’ve had the privilege of listening to members, partners and teams working within neighbourhoods across the country. I’ve heard about what is working, what is getting in the way and, importantly, what seems to be different in places that are making progress.
I certainly do not have all the answers. But a year of listening, learning and asking questions has reinforced a few things for me about where neighbourhood health needs to go next.
We need a magnifying glass, not a megaphone
When I started this role, I wanted to approach it with a magnifying glass rather than a megaphone.
Before deciding what NAPC should say, I wanted to understand what people were actually experiencing.
In a system under significant pressure, it is natural to reach quickly for solutions. But curiosity creates some space before the answer. It allows us to ask:
- What is really going on here?
- What does this look like from the perspective of the person receiving care?
- What are practitioners experiencing?
- And what might we be missing because we are looking at the problem through an organisational lens?
I think that curiosity has become more important as neighbourhood health has moved from an interesting idea to a national policy ambition.
Start with the problem, not the structure
Last year, I was walking in Wadebridge in Cornwall when I came across its historic bridge.
The story goes that, hundreds of years ago, crossing the river was dangerous and people were dying. The response was not to create more ways of dealing with the consequences when things went wrong. Instead, the local community addressed the conditions creating the problem and built a bridge using the resources available to them.
For me, there are three useful disciplines in that story:
- Start with the local problem.
- Use the assets that already exist in the community.
- Build something durable rather than a temporary workaround.
That is a helpful way to think about neighbourhood health.
A bridge is not another organisation. It is something that connects people and places. Our challenge is similar: how do we create the shared purpose, relationships and capabilities that allow people to move through health and care without repeatedly falling into the gaps between our organisations and services?
We can spend a lot of time debating exactly what a neighbourhood is.
- Is it a geography?
- A primary care network?
- An integrated team?
- A collection of pathways?
Those definitions will continue to develop. But we should not allow the search for the perfect definition to prevent progress.
For me, neighbourhood health is fundamentally about organising services, resources and decisions around a defined population, rather than expecting the population to organise itself around our institutions. It is a change in mindset and ways of working before it is a change in structure.
Relationships are part of the infrastructure
Through NAPC’s work with neighbourhoods, including supporting 16 sites through the National Neighbourhood Health Implementation Programme (NNHIP), I have seen just how difficult this transformation can be.
When services are under pressure, organisations naturally look inwards. Thresholds can rise and significant amounts of time can be spent managing interfaces between services rather than solving problems together.
Where I have seen things beginning to work differently, people have instead asked: What does each partner bring?
Primary care, community services, mental health, social care, local government, the voluntary sector and communities themselves all bring different strengths and assets. The aim is not to create another service sitting above them. It is to help existing teams behave more like one team around a shared understanding of the population they serve.
One of my strongest reflections from the year is that relationships are not a soft extra. They are part of the delivery infrastructure.
Trust reduces the effort required to navigate organisational boundaries. When people know one another, understand what each partner contributes and have a shared purpose, they are better able to solve problems together.
We often reach first for structure because structure is visible. But changing the boxes on an organisational chart does not automatically change the behaviour between them.
Data matters, but so does wisdom
The NHS has no shortage of data. We can count admissions, referrals, activity, workforce and many other measures.
But neighbourhood working depends on our ability to move beyond counting and understand context.
I often use a tomato analogy to explain this, building on a line widely attributed to British journalist and humorist Miles Kington. Data may tell us that we have ten tomatoes. Information tells us that eight are edible. Knowledge tells us a tomato is a fruit. Wisdom tells us not to put it in a fruit salad.
The point is that a metric can tell us that something is changing, but rarely tells us why.
To understand that, we need to listen to people doing the work and people receiving care. We need professional judgement and local knowledge alongside the numbers.
Neighbourhoods need to be able to ask:
- What does this data mean for this particular population, with these particular assets, relationships and constraints?
- And what are we going to do with what we now know?
People live one life, not a collection of services
Accountability is another issue that has come up repeatedly.
In the webinar, I described the example of a woman with learning disabilities whose circumstances involved her housing, asthma and allergies, caring responsibilities, general practice, emergency care, social care, learning disability services, pharmacy and her family.
Who is accountable?
The GP? The hospital? Housing? Social care? The pharmacist? Her family? The woman herself?
No single organisation can realistically be accountable for that entire situation. That is not necessarily a failure of governance. It is the reality of complexity.
Yet from her perspective, she experiences one life, not a series of separate statutory accountabilities.
Perhaps the better questions are:
- What are we collectively trying to achieve?
- And what contribution is each person and organisation accountable for?
We can still have clear professional and organisational responsibilities. We can make decision-making explicit, share information appropriately and establish routes for managing risk. But alongside individual accountability, we also need mutual responsibility for how the system works together around a person.
Improving today while building tomorrow
Perhaps one of the greatest tensions facing neighbourhood health is the need to deliver for people today while also creating healthier communities for the future.
Leaders understandably want to see early improvements, whether that is reducing avoidable admissions, improving discharge, ensuring appropriate referrals, improving access or reducing pressure.
But meaningful neighbourhood transformation takes years.
Move too slowly and neighbourhood health risks being dismissed as a worthy aspiration. Move too quickly and narrowly and it can become a collection of hospital avoidance schemes focused solely on people at the highest risk.
Those schemes can be valuable, but they are not, by themselves, a new operating model.
We therefore have to do two things at once: improve today’s services while building tomorrow’s healthier communities.
That means progressively shifting our attention upstream towards prevention, health creation, shared decision-making and stronger communities, while continuing to deliver tangible benefits now.
And this cannot become an NHS-owned project. Local government, the voluntary sector and communities themselves are essential partners, often with a deeper understanding of what is happening locally and what might make a difference.
So, what comes next?
Over the next year, NAPC will continue working with neighbourhoods and systems on the practical development of neighbourhood health.
Leadership will be a major part of that, but not leadership defined simply by job title. We need people with the capability to work across boundaries, build shared purpose and create the conditions in which teams can work differently.
We will also continue contributing to discussions about contracting models, asking how contracts can enable neighbourhood working rather than allowing form to come before function.
Alongside this, we have begun work on the future of general practice in a neighbourhood context, looking at what needs to be preserved, what needs to change and how general practice can remain relational and local while becoming a stronger partner at scale. NAPC is also working with the Queen’s Institute of Community Nursing on practice nursing, an area I believe deserves greater attention within discussions about the future of primary care.
A year into this role, I am probably left with more questions than answers. I do not think that is a bad thing.
We need to be clear about the direction without pretending we have every answer.
Start with the problem and the population, not the organisation.
Build relationships as seriously as we build structures.
Use evidence, but keep learning.
And recognise that the real work of neighbourhood health is not simply structural change. It is about leadership, culture, relationships and continuous improvement.
If we can hold onto those principles, I think we have a real opportunity not simply to reorganise care, but to change how people and communities experience it.


